Kirin’s View on Reports Issued by Proxy Advisory Firms
Kirin Holdings Company, Limited (“Kirin” or “the Company”) today made the following statement in response to reports issued by proxy advisory firms Institutional Shareholder Services Inc. (“ISS”) and Glass Lewis regarding the election of directors to Kirin’s Board of Directors (“Board”) and other proposals at the Company’s Ordinary General Meeting on March 27, 2020.
We appreciate that ISS and Glass Lewis recognize the incremental skills and strong independent perspectives that our recommended directors will bring to the Board. We are also pleased that ISS and Glass Lewis acknowledge our proactive efforts to strengthen governance by refreshing the Board and our commitment to continuously evaluate the Company’s strategy and performance to ensure it maximizes value creation for all shareholders.
Additionally, we welcome ISS and Glass Lewis’ agreement with us that Independent Franchise Partners’ (“FP”) proposal for additional share buybacks funded by divestitures introduces several significant issues.
We strongly believe that this buyback proposal is reckless and a case of short-term financial engineering. In KV2027 (Long-Term Management Vision “Kirin Group Vision 2027”), recognizing the structural challenges within the Japan beer market and social trends promoting health and well-being, we believe continuing to invest judiciously in adjacent markets – across the food, health science, and pharmaceuticals – that leverage the Company's core competencies in fermentation and biotechnology will best position Kirin for growth over the long term. We are not building a conglomerate of disparate businesses, but instead a company with inter-connected and synergistic businesses rooted in our long-standing expertise.
Furthermore, we are encouraged that Glass Lewis recognizes that Kirin’s proposed director remuneration is appropriate. The Nomination and Remuneration Advisory Committee appreciates the importance of continuous review of the remuneration system, following an extensive review of industry best practices with the assistance of external compensation consultants. We believe our proposed remuneration system already has a high ratio of performance-based to total pay of remuneration.
Following are additional comments addressing the various recommendations made by ISS and Glass Lewis.
Our position on ISS' recommendations
[Proposal 2: Our Views on the Appointment of Directors (Company Proposal)]
Regarding the Nomination of Toshiya Miyoshi.
We disagree with ISS’ decision to recommend against Toshiya Miyoshi. ISS’ report notes that its recommendation is due to its belief that his area of responsibility is less critical to the issues surrounding FP’s proxy contest. However, Mr. Miyoshi brings strong human resources expertise that plays a critical role in supporting our strategy.
Mr. Miyoshi has abundant business experience and deep knowledge in human resources, labor relations, and marketing. Since joining the Board, he has provided meaningful counsel on Kirin’s marketing and brand strategies as well as its human resources and employee engagement initiatives.
Additionally, Mr. Miyoshi has made significant contributions to Kirin’s structural and management reforms, including the strengthening of the Company’s corporate governance. He is also a member of the Nomination and Remuneration Advisory Committee.
Given his human resources and personnel management expertise, Mr. Miyoshi provides invaluable contributions to our company's medium- to long-term value creation strategy and our commitment to Creating Shared Value (CSV).
ISS mentions that the reason of the recommendation to vote against Mr. Miyoshi is to nominate one of the dissident’s nominees, which we believe it’s rather a passive approach. We believe that Mr. Miyoshi will continue to be an integral part of our efforts to enhance shareholder value.
[Proposal 4: Our Views on Proposed Changes to Director Remuneration (Company Proposal)]
ISS recommended against the Company’s proposed changes to director remuneration (Proposal No. 4) which would introduce a trust-type stock-based remuneration system with a limit of 600 million yen for directors, while endorsing FP’s proposed compensation changes (Proposal No. 7) which would increase the ceiling to 1.2 billion yen per year for the stock remuneration with restriction of transfer, in addition to the base pay and bonuses paid to our directors.
The Nomination and Remuneration Advisory Committee proposed a new trust-type stock compensation system, following consultation with external advisors and an extensive review of peer and industry best practices.
Our newly proposed trust-type stock compensation system will greatly reduce the burden of the Board resolutions compared with the past restricted stock compensation system and will enable us to concentrate on management supervision.
The underlying metrics determining performance-based remuneration are transparent and closely linked to the Company’s ability to create value for its shareholders and execute its strategy. These include ROIC and normalized EPS as well as the newly introduced non-financial performance metrics critical to the Company’s CSV initiatives.
We believe the Company's proposed director remuneration system better supports long-term value creation relative to FP’s proposed program, which simply calls for an increase in the shareholding compensation ceiling for directors.
The system will be continuously monitored by the Board and The Nomination and Remuneration Advisory Committee and amended, following comprehensive discussion among them.
Our position on Glass Lewis’ recommendations
[Proposal 2: Our Views on the Appointment of Directors (Company Proposal)]
Glass Lewis recommended that shareholders oppose two of the Company’s non-executive director candidates, Hiroyuki Yanagi and Noriko Shiono.
Regarding the Nomination of Hiroyuki Yanagi
We believe that Glass Lewis has misunderstood Hiroyuki Yanagi’s ability to contribute to the Board in characterizing him as “overboarded.” This ignores his strong record as an engaged director – last year Mr. Yanagi attended all 12 Kirin board meetings and was actively involved in boardroom discussions on matters important to the Company.
Given Mr. Yanagi’s high level of engagement and deep understanding of Kirin’s business, as well as his strong business management expertise, we believe he is well suited to continue to contribute to our Board.
Regarding the Nomination of Noriko Shiono
We are disappointed with Glass Lewis’ decision to recommend against Noriko Shiono due in large part to her role as a strategic advisor to the Company.
Ms. Shiono was appointed to this position, which is equivalent to non-executive director, following the reorganization of Japan Integrated Beverages company, in which she previously served as a non-executive director. We believe Glass Lewis’ recommendation is in part based on the incorrect belief – stated in its report – that Ms. Shiono played an integral role in the development of Kirin's KV 2027. Rather, her role was truly independent to the company and we believe there are no underlying conflicts.
We are confident given Ms. Shiono’s strong track record as Representative Director of pharmaceuticals manufacturer SS Pharmaceuticals Co., Ltd. that she will take an unbiased, critical view in evaluating the Company’s strategic direction. Ms. Shiono will bring valuable expertise in health sciences and pharmaceuticals that will be critical as we continue to drive incremental synergies from our existing businesses and pursue high-growth opportunities in these fields that leverage Kirin’s strength and long-standing expertise in fermentation and biotechnology.
Importantly, Glass Lewis’ report supports Ms. Shiono’s status as an outside independent director. The report stated that seven outside director members are all independent, and that the Board structure, in which outside director accounts for the majority, is rare among Japanese companies. We believe Ms. Shiono will be a strong independent voice on the Board, and that her knowledge and experiences in health science and pharmaceuticals will contribute to maximizing shareholder value.
We urge our shareholders to consider the above when exercising their voting rights.
While Kirin disagrees with some aspects of Glass Lewis and ISS' conclusions, their reports made important points on Board independence, governance, remuneration, FP’s proposals and Company performance for Kirin shareholders to consider in advance of voting at the Company’s Ordinary General Meeting, including1:
“At the forthcoming annual general meeting of shareholders, the Company has nominated twelve directors to the board, including seven outside directors, all of whom we consider to be truly independent. We commend the Company for proposing to have majority of its board to be comprised of truly independent directors, a practice which is rare in Japan.” (Glass Lewis)
“As classified by ISS, independence (excluding statutory auditors) increases from 33 percent to 50 percent. As a reference, Asahi has nine board members, including three independents, according to ISS. The proposed Kirin board would include two women and two foreigners, vs. none a year ago.” (ISS)
“We note that the Company released its convocation notice on February 25, more than four weeks prior to the shareholder meeting. We commend the Company for disclosing this important information pertaining to the annual meeting in advance.” (Glass Lewis)
“Though under Japanese law, companies are only required to disclose attendance records of external board members, the Company has voluntarily released attendance records for all directors, including inside directors, for board meetings held during the last fiscal year. We commend the Company for such practices and encourage it to continue to improve director attendance disclosure.” (Glass Lewis)
“We believe that the Company's existing compensation scheme is appropriate.” (Glass Lewis)
“We believe that the Company should retain the flexibility to create compensation packages for its directors and auditors that are in line with their peers and commensurate with their services.” (Glass Lewis)
“We believe the resolution (surrounding [FP]'s alternative share buyback proposal) introduces a number of significant issues.” (Glass Lewis)
“We consider the implications of [FP]'s buyback resolution are problematically ambiguous, and the resolution is, at best, an inefficient mechanism for purposes of expressing more granular concern with KV2027.” (Glass Lewis)
“It seems premature to support the shareholder buyback proposal based on selling the stakes in Kyowa Kirin and FANCL at this time.” (ISS)
Company Performance and TSR
“In particular we acknowledge Kirin did indeed outperform its domestic and international rivals from the time of Mr. Isozaki's appointment through the last trading date prior to emergence of [FP].” (Glass Lewis)
“Kirin should be credited for a successful turnaround and return to profitability.” (ISS)
Kirin’s board reminds shareholders that their vote is extremely important, no matter how many or how few shares they own. Kirin urges shareholders to vote FOR ALL the Company’s proposals.
1 Permission to quote from report was neither sought nor obtained.
Kirin Holdings Co., Ltd.
Corporate Communications Department
About Business Wire
Subscribe to releases from Business Wire
Subscribe to all the latest releases from Business Wire by registering your e-mail address below. You can unsubscribe at any time.
Latest releases from Business Wire
Spotify Launches in Russia and 12 Additional European Markets14.7.2020 19:30:00 CEST | Press release
Spotify (NYSE: SPOT) today launched its service in 13 new markets across Europe including Russia, one of the world’s top 20 largest streaming markets. Already the world’s most popular audio streaming subscription service, with today’s expansion, Spotify now reaches a current total of 92 markets worldwide. Spotify’s 13 new markets include: Albania, Belarus, Bosnia & Herzegovina, Croatia, Kazakhstan, Kosovo, Moldova, Montenegro, North Macedonia, Russia, Serbia, Slovenia, Ukraine. As the leading platform driving music discovery on more types of devices than any other service, Spotify’s expansion in Europe comes as consumers in the region embrace streaming. According to the International Federation of the Phonographic Industry (IFPI), Russia is the 17th-biggest streaming market in the world and on pace to be the 10th-biggest streaming market by 2030. More than 87 percent of fans in Russia now access music through streaming, compared to 61 percent adoption globally, and 68 percent adoption
Pietro Rosa TBM Signs Multi-year Agreement With Boeing to Supply Titanium Forgings14.7.2020 18:08:00 CEST | Press release
Pietro Rosa TBM is proud to announce that it has signed a long-term agreement with Boeing to supply forgings for use on the 787 Dreamliner, 777X and 737 MAX airplanes. This press release features multimedia. View the full release here: https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20200714005848/en/ Left to right: Mauro Fioretti (Pietro Rosa TBM - President & CEO), Antonio De Palmas (Boeing Italy – President) (Photo: Business Wire) The agreement covers a variety of Titanium forgings and represents the first long-term agreement to be placed with Pietro Rosa TBM since the company’s milestone approvals with Boeing in 2018, enhancing Pietro Rosa TBM ability to enact its strategy for the provision of complex forged structural components. The deal with Boeing further reinforces the Pietro Rosa Groups' supply of products in North America. Mauro Fioretti, President and CEO of the Pietro Rosa Group, stated: “This commitment and great trust placed in us by Boeing further underpins our marketplace strat
Kollective Technology to Demonstrate Scalability of Microsoft Teams and Stream Live Events at Microsoft Experience and Technology Centers Worldwide14.7.2020 17:18:00 CEST | Press release
Leading Software-Defined Enterprise Content Delivery Network (SD ECDN) provider Kollective Technology today announced that it was selected by Microsoft Corp. (Nasdaq: MSFT) to demonstrate the scalability of Microsoft Teams for live events at Microsoft Experience and Technology Centers worldwide. Designed to create comprehensive and immersive technology experiences for Microsoft customers looking to adopt innovations that accelerate their Digital Transformation initiatives, Microsoft Experience and Technology Centers highlight the latest in Modern Workplace use cases, including live video broadcasts. By selecting Kollective as the certified ECDN of Experience Centers, Microsoft can now easily showcase how Teams can deliver company-wide, global live events with the help of ECDN technology. Kollective’s ECDN platform, utilizing browser-based peering technology, scales Teams live events without the need to install software or invest in additional network infrastructure. Leveraging the Koll
rf IDEAS wins the HP ® JetAdvantage 2020 Partner Award for Customer Focus14.7.2020 17:00:00 CEST | Press release
rf IDEAS is proud to have received the HP JetAdvantage Partner Award for Customer Focus, presented by HP during its 2020 Partner Conference, held online for participant safety from May 18 to May 22. This press release features multimedia. View the full release here: https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20200714005170/en/ HP JetAdvantage Partner Award for Customer Focus (Photo: Business Wire) rf IDEAS is a leading manufacturer of credential readers for logical access and authentication. The HP JetAdvantage Partner Program offers services and resources to help solution providers accelerate development, simplify deployment and streamline integration with HP imaging and printing devices. Through the program, HP and rf IDEAS have worked together for more than 12 years to bring contactless authentication and identification to HP enterprise applications and to HP JetAdvantage Solutions Partners worldwide. One quality that sets rf IDEAS apart is the company’s unwavering commitment to custome
Andersen Global Enters Trinidad and Tobago14.7.2020 15:30:00 CEST | Press release
Andersen Global continues its expansion in the Caribbean by way of a Collaboration Agreement with full-service tax firm Robley Baynes, marking the organization’s debut in Trinidad and Tobago. Established in 2018, the firm provides a full scope of services including tax and advisory, financial, corporate and management. Led by Partners Kendell Robley and Mikhail Baynes, the dynamic and innovative firm assists clients with value-added solutions focused on business improvement and growth, leveraging their resources and experience across a wide range of client engagements. “We constantly strive to provide best-in-class, client-focused solutions with a high-caliber team of professionals,” Kendell and Mikhail said. “Our collaboration with Andersen Global will allow us to expand our capacity and global footprint, bringing opportunities for broader and more seamless service globally.” “We are delighted to work with Kendall, Mikhail and their team in Trinidad and Tobago. Collaborating with Robl
FINEOS Welcomes Allison Morgan as New Senior Sales Executive for North America14.7.2020 15:15:00 CEST | Press release
FINEOS Corporation (ASX:FCL), the leading core platform for life, accident and health insurance globally, today announces the appointment of Allison Morgan as Senior Sales Executive to the FINEOS North American team. This press release features multimedia. View the full release here: https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20200714005639/en/ Allison Morgan (Photo: Business Wire) Allison brings nearly 25 years of proven experience as an accomplished absence and disability sales leader and consultant with powerful relationship building, negotiation, communication and presentation skills. She has a proven track record and demonstrated ability to obtain, grow and retain a customer base to support organizational objectives. In her new role at FINEOS, Allison will be responsible for developing new business clients for FINEOS Claims, FINEOS Absence and FINEOS AdminSuite. Alison’s expertise in absence management is especially important as Integrated Disability and Absence management (IDAM) beco
In our pressroom you can read all our latest releases, find our press contacts, images, documents and other relevant information about us.Visit our pressroom